1. Squarum: The Modern Standard
Squarum takes the top spot because it solves the biggest problem in identity governance: Complexity.
While traditional tools require months of “implementation projects,” Squarum is built for speed.
- Zero Infrastructure: As a pure SaaS platform, there is no self-hosting, no server maintenance, and no complex installation. You can literally start your first review on Day 1.
- Automated Workflows: It replaces manual chasing with automated email notifications and “App Owner” portals.
- Audit-Ready: It generates tamper-proof evidence and reports automatically, making it the fastest way to satisfy auditors for frameworks like ISO 27001 or SOC2.
- The “Easy” Factor: Unlike its competitors, Squarum doesn’t require a dedicated team of engineers to keep it running. It’s designed to be intuitive enough for business managers to use without a manual.
2. Microsoft Excel
Best for: Micro-teams with 5–15 employees and zero budget (if you have a valid license).
Excel remains the most common “free” tool for access reviews. If you are a very small startup, you can manually export user lists into a spreadsheet and send them around for sign-off.
- Pros: (Almost) everyone knows how to use it; it costs nothing if you already have an Office 365 license.
- Cons: It is incredibly painful to scale. You have no audit trail (anyone can edit a cell), no automated reminders, and “version control” becomes a nightmare once you have more than five applications to review.
The Verdict: Great for your first-ever review, but you’ll want to move to Squarum as soon as you have more than 15+ employees.
3. OpenIAM (Community Edition)
Best for: Large organizations with heavy technical resources who must self-host.
OpenIAM offers a free “Community Edition” that provides a professional-grade Identity Governance and Administration (IGA) suite. It is much more powerful than a spreadsheet, but it comes with a catch.
- Professional Features: Unlike Excel, OpenIAM includes actual access certification workflows and can connect to various systems to pull data.
- The Complexity Barrier: Unlike Squarum, OpenIAM is self-hosted. This means your IT team must install it, manage the database, handle security updates, and provide the infrastructure to run it.
- Steep Learning Curve: It is a robust, “heavy” tool. While the software itself is free, the “hidden costs” in terms of engineering hours for setup and maintenance are significant.
Feature
Squarum
Excel
OpenIAM (CE)
Setup Time
Minutes (SaaS)
Days
Weeks
Ease of Use
Very Easy
Easy
Not easy
Automation
Full
None
High
Self-hosting
No (SaaS)
Yes
Yes, required
Audit Readiness
Automated Reports
Manual / Weak
Professional
Summary
If you have a massive IT team and a requirement to keep everything on your own servers, OpenIAM is a solid free choice. If you’re tiny, Excel works in a pinch. But for the vast majority of modern companies, Squarum is the clear winner—it offers the power of a professional tool with the “plug-and-play” simplicity that saves hundreds of hours of manual labor.